25 July 2006 @ 10:06 am
SGA: 3x01-3x02  
I've been trying to find words for how I felt about the first two episodes. And I'm still having trouble.

The thing is, you just don't create gaping holes like that!! Because since when, can Atlanits just dial earth on a whim. I thought the ZPM wasn't that full? Dialing earth takes up a huge amount of energy.

Also, regarding the morals of the whole arc and stuff. I'm not sure how I would act in a military situation. I'm not sure if an offenseive gesture in a case like this is better than a defensive one. I'm not military, but I don't like the fact, that none of the decisions were questioned. Not once. Not in Michael, not in Allies and not in these two episodes. It is just a them or me attitude and we do not see everything that is going on. Like we didn't see Elizabeth making the decision. We were just presented with it. Which is sloppy writing imo. I want to see the motivation more.

I liked Elizhabeth in the first part, but I did think the whole argument got repetitive in the second part. I mean, she had the same conversation in the first one.


THIS is what they did with Michael? (Is that eyeliner?)

Don't make SGA too much like SG1 please. that is what SG1 is for.

Actually, "No man's Land" is the first time that I liked Elizabeth Weir.

I loved it when Teyla squealed "John" in the beginning.

I loved the briefing room scene *g* No surprise there. Rodney and John especially rocked in this.
"She feels hungry, too?"

"Does flying in a straight line count as a maneuver?"
"No"

Holodock!!!! Though maybe he should talk less shit ;)

"Nothing renews your appreciation for the military like the threat of invasion from life-sucking aliens."

I wonder if they did something else to poor Carson, there... like maybe..a virus. Or something... or maybe Michael is permanently in his head.

John is still teh sexy ::

And now to more meta, if it can count as such.

First of all, my interpretation of John's defensiveness in regards to Woolsey is totally different form everyone elses. I think it mainly has to do with the fact, that I don't beleive Elizabeth made the decisions about michael all on her own.

But just remember wo John is... he's got a black mark, or at least something in his record that makes him stand out as being weary of authority figures. He solely got the position, because of Liz. They wanted Caldwell to do the job. So he gets into this meeting and basically, for him it must feel like a small trial. He must have been there before. Am I making any sense?

Oh, and I read loads of dicussion about John and The Flan's acting. And is it really the truth that John was supposed to be some hardass military dude? I mean, just remember the background. Just remember him in comparison to Sumner. That cannot just be the delivery.

And mind you, John got me into watching SGA. Or rather..into keeping to watch it. I would never have stuck around if he weren't that quirky, weird, maybe mysterious dude. I would never have watched! so I do wonder what the intentions are.

I love that my show is back btw... I love the one liners and the character interaction, I just hope they get on an even footing with the story-telling.

 
 
( Post a new comment )
[identity profile] sprungl.livejournal.com on July 25th, 2006 12:22 pm (UTC)
some random girl :P
Love the review I just finished watching the episodes yesterday.
I agree with you completely about mostly everything,really!:P
Love this one the most:
John is still teh sexy :: :P

And yes the story telling is a bit sloppy!Lets hope the next episode improves a bit!

p.s.:took some of your icons,they are all amazingly creative!:))thank you!
[identity profile] elli.livejournal.com on July 25th, 2006 02:26 pm (UTC)
Re: some random girl :P
*giggles*

Well yeah, and I was rather incoherent here as well. I just wish I could make more sense of it all.

And I hope so too...and lots of great banter!!!

And thank you :)
[identity profile] miriam.livejournal.com on July 25th, 2006 01:54 pm (UTC)
Wow, you pretty much just said in your meta what I thought about the first two eps of the new season. My first reaction? "Wtf, why are they dialing to SGC?" So, I am there with you to 100%; I wondered about the very same things, and, yes, I am morally totally appalled by how they just do it this way (either us or them) and make it sound like the ideal solution. Wraith or not, you cannot just do that imo.
[identity profile] elli.livejournal.com on July 25th, 2006 02:28 pm (UTC)
Yeah..I mean..they did it right away and there was just NO explanation... it doesn't only seem sloppy.. it seasm careless. And I need themn to care.

And I'm no soldier... I think, if there was any explanation..but alas.. the Wraith and especially were portrayed much thoroughly and you emphazize.

Not like in sg1.. where the goaould are just bad bad bad.
[identity profile] miriam.livejournal.com on August 4th, 2006 09:27 pm (UTC)
Okay, Marge explained to me why the can just go back to the SGC like that. Still, the whole Wraith thing.. giving me major moral goosebumps. *sigh* Anyway, I did a major real life rant on the writing of SGA some days ago, and I don't want to repeat myself here. Just that I.. expect a bit more of a show that's so great in so many other ways. Poor writing is inexusable if you look how many talented writers are out there.. *sigh*
[identity profile] stabbim.livejournal.com on July 25th, 2006 05:18 pm (UTC)
It is just a them or me attitude and we do not see everything that is going on. *snip* Don't make SGA too much like SG1 please. that is what SG1 is for.

Huh? Not fair. Both shows suck in that regard. Big time. Always have. This isn't new. The only difference is that SG-1 has (more or less) successfully found and kept certain allies to battle the Goa'uld and the Ori. Amazing, considering that they're treating their Russian colleagues like shit. But how many allies have SGA discovered by applying the same "them or us"-attitude? Didn't work out so well with the Genii, eh? I hate it that they are so full of themselves.

[identity profile] elli.livejournal.com on July 26th, 2006 10:36 am (UTC)
Actually, it is like that with most shows, I just think the< walk a fine line with what they show and what they don't and here... they just don't show enough.

And yeah... and the poor Russion commander... who I rwally liked...just had to bite the dust!

And yeah... although it couldn't be helped with the Genii, nothing really sticks.. or they just don't bring it up.
[identity profile] stabbim.livejournal.com on July 26th, 2006 11:07 am (UTC)
Actually, it is like that with most shows, I just think the< walk a fine line with what they show and what they don't and here... they just don't show enough.

Yeah, I know what you mean. I thought they had a good opportunity here, and they wasted it. It'd be nice if they took risks sometimes or showed that cooperation is important/necessary to survive. To me, that's the essence of sci-fi. To show the world that it's got to stick together, no matter how hard or impossible it seems.

And yeah... and the poor Russion commander... who I rwally liked...just had to bite the dust!

I thought he had potential. I also thought Peter Grodin had potential and then they killed him off. :(

And yeah... although it couldn't be helped with the Genii, nothing really sticks.. or they just don't bring it up.

Too bad, really. I mean, it's okay that things didn't work out with the Genii, but it'd be great to see more interaction with other well-developed civilizations, y'know? Not that I'm a huge fan of the Tollans or Tok'ra, but they showed us that we aren't the top of the food chain, and I'm a bit sad that the Asguard have been reduced to ship drivers instead of helping Dr. Beckett by joining him on his research projects et cetera. There's so much they could do, y'know? Not that I'm complaining, I enjoy watching the shows, but sometimes I wish there'd be more layers to peel off...
[identity profile] elli.livejournal.com on July 26th, 2006 11:52 am (UTC)
Yeah, I know what you mean. I thought they had a good opportunity here, and they wasted it. It'd be nice if they took risks sometimes or showed that cooperation is important/necessary to survive. To me, that's the essence of sci-fi. To show the world that it's got to stick together, no matter how hard or impossible it seems.

There is nothing more important than continuity and hopefully developement especially for the characters. Not have stuff just pass by them.


I thought he had potential. I also thought Peter Grodin had potential and then they killed him off. :(


Well, Grodin I do understand.It's a character that becomes dear to you, that you care about, but not a regular. You show this way that there is mortal danger... it is still sad. He was one of my favorites. And not just because I remembered him from Dark Angel.

And yes, the Asgard are being totally misused. I'd love a story where sg1 goes to their planet to help rebuild or something.
[identity profile] prettybutt.livejournal.com on July 26th, 2006 12:27 pm (UTC)
i still have the second episode on my DVR for me, so i kind of skipped this--will comment when I am fully caught up. Might i mention, Ronan + Lazer Gun=Sex. BTW happy birthday--so sorry I missed it, but a little something something at my lj for you. Off to back track through these posts. I missed a lot these past few weeks. take care-l
[identity profile] elli.livejournal.com on July 27th, 2006 11:28 am (UTC)
*giggles* Yeah..Ronan and his gun...and his facial expressions rock!

Adn thank you... you had more important things to worry about, just make sure that you take care of yourself. *huggles*